Summary

The cookie dough here is pretty sweet.

Tried multiple flavors, but all of them are all pretty sweet. I also used some of the batter and baked some cookies. They turned out ok, though no different than if you to were make regular cookies. One scoop by the way makes about 5 ok sized cookies.

Honestly, I thought the one of the better things to get was not the dough itself, but the ice cream sandwich. It’s 2 cookie doughs with DO ice cream smashed in between. The ice cream was a nice counter balance to the super sweetness of the cookie dough.

Final Verdict

Try the cookie dough if it’s your first time. Otherwise stick to the ice cream sandwich if you need a safe bet.

Yelp Jabs

Granted, I’ve never been a cookie dough person so don’t quite understood why people like eating the stuff. But notwithstanding, this place overall seemed very overhyped and like a stereotypical gimmicky food idea that’s trendy for a year or two before fading out.

Someone doesn’t like cookie dough and rates the place low becuase of it as if they thought it could change their mind. One would have to ask, “Why did you go to it anyways?” Makes perfect sense in the world of these Yelpers.

Vegan options are terrible… We took 2 trains and walked 10 min for this strong disappointment. Also floors, walls and baseboards very dirty.

The world is a little small for expansive vegan options, even in New York City. Maybe San Francisco is better suited for this person.